• Hello Guest, welcome to the initial stages of our new platform!
    You can find some additional information about where we are in the process of migrating the board and setting up our new software here

    Thank you for being a part of our community!

Snapped Whiteblock Head bolt in block…dissolve w/nitric acid or Alum?

Kjets On a Plane

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 12, 2002
Location
Californicated Oregone
Soo…
…it’s been a long time since I’ve done this (and kind of can’t believe I did / kind of know better?), but managed snap the bolt extractor off after drilling a lovely centered hole with a guide bushing and plenty of pressure on the bit all the way thru the remaining ~2” of head bolt.:raincloud:

Drilling the extractor looks neigh impossible or really annoying.
There’s no particular hurry.
Sooner would be better, but the car doesn’t need to leave tmw and lower risk and less frustration preferred?

Broken whiteblock head bolts usually jump right out with a quick bop with the punch, overnight soak in oil and a little heat…
…idk if I got a little impatient or what, exactly, but it’s STUCK.
‘98 V70 T5 and it’s the expected (in my limited turbo whiteblock experience…hope it stays that way?) middle back 2 bolts closest to the manifold collector.

Given dissimilar metals and that it’ll probably take a day + to lap all the valves (burned valve is where the journey began, head flat / didn’t overheat otherwise?).

There’s no huge hurry and it’s broken off 2” below the block deck where the threads start, how about just dissolving it after acetone soaking and blowing it with the air gun plenty 1st?

The 2 x 1/2” dia hole below the head should hold the acid solution reasonably well?

Tape the block deck w/some duct tape / similar and replace the acid with fresh with the mity vac or syringe pipet every so often?
Difficult to stir it &/or give it even exposure to the ferrous bolt at the moment?

Masonry bit or some other source of carbide bit might be effective to remove the extractor (if not the bolt itself?) and I probably only have to drill ~3/8” into the broken piece of fluted extractor if it really comes to that to dissolve the ferrous metal from the inside out. :oops:

Any of you do this at home w/primitive tools and grocery store spice aisle supplies?


Flask, virgin material and (chaotic?) lab it is not, can I get it clean enough and solution to flow around the ferrous bolt in the alloy block blind water tight hole well enough?

Doesn’t seem prudent to leave pedestaled heat gun blowing on it…I wonder if i have an old block heater or glow plug I can use on some kind of basic thermostatic / temp sensor on/ off circuit to warm the block to ~150F in a 50-60F (insulated but not heated) garage I can install somewhere?

Evaporation and other concerns?

Distilled water or heat pump water heater condensate filtered a bit sans minerals or chlorine?

Idk where I’d obtain a paristaltic pump to better circulate the solution in the blind hole if the quantity of Alum solution in the recessed hole proved insufficient?
 
Last edited:
^It’s fairly common on whiteblocks of this age, but usually the car isn’t worth fixing unless special model or in pretty good condition (& even then, debatable?).

It’s usually the back (on an FWD) middle 2 bolts in the blind holes by the manifold collector that snap on removal on these.

Never had one actually stick like this tho?
Maybe the grease on the head bolt (and bolt itself?) has just been baking by the manifold collector for so long / almost 30 years now?
Lot of temp cycles on a high pressure turbo model possible in that time.

Good news is head came right off in ~1.5hrs actual work time?
(I don’t have it quite down to 45mins like the true whiteblock pros that do/ did tons of these miserable things).

Next time I’ll warm the block carefully with the mapp torch and try to gently rock the center rear head bolts back and forth a bit more as I can usually get them out, or, if they do snap, relieve the pressure so they spin right out?

I tend to coat the underside of the head bolts in the thickest lead-zync anti-seize so they don’t pop on tightening/torquing and similar with the threads, but wipe that portion them back off so it’s the thinnest possible oily silvery coating (don’t want them to rust?) as they can & do easily hydrolock in some of the blind holes in the whiteblock / seen people mess that up.

Otherwise, it seems ‘fine’ to reuse head bolts on them after carefully cleaning the holes if they’re not pitted or stretched from a nuclear overheat for the many reasons the heads have to come off these miserable things.

Idk if I can control this properly for:
-heat
-cleanliness / oil contamination
-fresh solution &/or circulation thereof.

I’ll see what I can cobble and maybe I can diamond bit and dental hand piece the broken extractor out so I can fill the hollow bolt with acetone and blow air and acetone between the bolt threads to try allow the solution to dissolve the ferrous bolt in the bind aluminum hole a bit better?

The solution seems to dull the aluminum a bit, but doesn’t pit or dissolve the alloy all that much?

Maybe I can get some pics of this disaster in progress…

I’m not particularly attached to this car, I just bought it because it had the same drivetrain code as my ‘98 V70R as well as 4 brand new tires on the same size rims (unsure if those will be used) to engage in some ‘swaptronics’ as opposed to correct diagnosis.

The blind hole into the dissimilar non ferrous / aluminum alloy metal with the stuck bolt broke off 2” recessed below the block deck is a crisis / challenge from a welding or mechanical means of extraction, but it (fortunately?) faces upward with ok access otherwise and should make a nice reservoir to contain a liquid chemical means of removal?
‘Don’t let a crisis go to waste.’
 
Last edited:
Can you find a sleeve, or drill out another bolt, and use it as a guide for a smaller drill to try to get the extractor out?

Maybe an aquarium pump, hose, and small air valve would work as a bubbler to stir the solution?
 
Left hand drill, if you use HSS it probably wont chew through the extractor remains but if the bit hooks it could break the bolt remains loose and turn it out. Id use a punch to break the extractor apart so you're drilling into the bolt.
 
Last edited:
Oh, I did measure and successfully drill all the way thru the remainder or the broken piece of head bolt fairly easily with a sleeve guide for a 1/4” left hand drill bit and old Volvo valve guide with some 2”masking tape wrapped tightly / neatly around it to keep it tight to the concentric recessed blind hole for 8mm stem valves (the nominal Volvo size) concentric to the hole for a 5/16” bit thru the 2” section of the M12x1-75 bolt.

Usually they spin right out with just the left handed bit when this has happened in the past with other whiteblocks with the tension relieved and no real corrosion in there most times (just some kind of crusty old baked oil?) / barely need to extract them, but I stupidly pounded the straight fluted extractor in the bolt and snapped it, which I am not proud of…

I could probably buy nicer carbide left hand bits (and still might?), and maybe soaking a few days in the oil it’ll now come out, but at year 28, it appears to be pretty cooked / seized in there?

At this point I sort of want to dental hand piece drill the ~3/8”deep embedded portion of extractor with the diamond bit and partially dissolve it in the Alum solution just because?

(just in the name of science and to learn a new method?) and also to partially dissolve a bolt I successfully drilled a fairly concentric 5/16 hole thru to wear as a necklace / on my keychain as a trophy like some kind of mad max bone necklace or keep on my keychain as a reminder that I’m an idiot / masochist (or something?)?
Is it a science, art or just an exercise in masochism & ??? At this point?

We’re into extra innings already, I own the car @ minimal cost / it’s not a customer car nor do I need it to get to work tmw (tho I hate dead cars and want it out of my
Crowded 2 car garage (really 1 car w/all the other stuff if you’ve got a crappy post WW2 attached garage defective truss roof house sans proper walk-out basement, attic, front & barn porch, mudroom, but I digress? ) and I’m <$50 into extractors and bits so far?

Tho, when I’d successfully carefully drilled the bolt (seemingly mostly concentrically?) all the way thru 2” deep in a 2” recess with the 2 slightly different sized left hand bits taking my time and ‘nothing bad had happened’ (but it also hadn’t moved like they usually do with just the left hand bit?)/ hadn’t broken the extractor maybe I was flying a little too close to the sun / got a little overly exuberant and impatient?…
…what is that they say that behind every secret fear is a secret wish (& vice-versa?)

I don’t do a ton of whiteblocks nor wrench on cars (if I can help it?) much at all these days my, but I’ve had this happen ~ 10x in the past (but also ~10-20+ years ago when burned valves, snapped tbelts, HGS / many / myriad of reasons for the head to come off these whiteblock junkers was commonplace when the cars & I were they much younger.

It wasn’t real common, but certainly not unheard of to snap a head bolt on a head R&R on these in the past…

I’ll look into pumping, heating, cleaning and drilling methods for the broken bit of extractor…

I’ve cleaned up the garage 2x, fixed the mapp gas torch, nearly lost my eyebrows with the torch with a little puddle of solvent I’d cleaned around the work area with and didn’t quite air dry well enough, found the left hand bits I prefer not to have need for?

‘clean the work area’ is the 1st step for so many construction projects and good documentation / tidy work habits are also important which I partially skipped / got a little impatient with.
Easier said than done?
 
Last edited:
Make friends with someone with a portable EDM? Locally?
That is a good higher budget ‘elegant experience’ option?

I do know someone that uses / has access one of those, but I doubt it can leave the jobsite?

But if it sits a couple days+ in the Alum after heating and changing out the solution until the fragment can be sufficiently reduced for removal and (hopefully?) become a strange keychain momento to remember which car’s keys are which, that’s should be fine?

The surplus lab, habistore and discount Asian / pickled spice aisle siren call / bug light tractor beam pull I fear is just too strong for a low budget TB scavenger / recycler that’s sort of determined to use whatever is common, proximate & oft discarded / derided?

Not that I’m opposed to borrowing or buying a fancy or special tool when I/ someone I know really needs one, will use it repeatedly &/or it fosters some curiosity in my 99% empty / useless brain and Office Space underachiever void levels of motivation & ambition?

Or can be acquired at a price & in a market or terms that that I can resell it easily and doesn’t take up too much space &/or require too much (expert or careful?) care and feeding?

‘*less* not more’ at this point in midlife is the drumbeat….
 
Last edited:
Dissolving the extractor sounds pretty cool. I vote try it and report back how it works for our collective enlightenment.

The only other that comes to mind is using a stud welder (like the ones meant for pulling body panel dents) to weld a stack of studs to the extractor/bolt, then weld a nut to the top of the stud and use the stud to spin it out.

Suggestion comes solely based on this video
(Sorry for the annoying YT Short format, but the info is good)
 
Dissolving the extractor sounds pretty cool. I vote try it and report back how it works for our collective enlightenment.

The only other that comes to mind is using a stud welder (like the ones meant for pulling body panel dents) to weld a stack of studs to the extractor/bolt, then weld a nut to the top of the stud and use the stud to spin it out.

Suggestion comes solely based on this video
(Sorry for the annoying YT Short format, but the info is good)
Stud welder in my experience don’t penetrate all that much on ticker steel

At least the one we got at work just times out after like 5-7 seconds
 
I'm in the exact same situation with my 850R, its uncanny how close this post hits home, except for the part with the bolt extractor.

I'm pretty close to just getting the damn engine out and sending it to a machine shop, so if any of you have breakthroughs it'll be welcome
 
I like the stud gun method?
It’d probably work ok on something as small as an M6 water pump bolt?
(especially as it cools or if the aluminum housing is heated a bit for the removal / expands a bit?)

Didn’t look real rusty in the vid, either? Just a little dirty idk?

Unfortunately, I no have a welder appropriate to fry something substantial to an M12 bolt (although I suppose you could try to slip something thru the hole in it after removing the extractor and fry that to the hollow bolt in my case?
I’d be a little afraid to try anything that would put sufficient heat to really melt to an M12 bolt down the hole?

It’s been sitting in the acetone overnight w/the hope of blowing the oil out from around it w/ the air gun today.

Alum acquired @ the .99¢ canning / Asian spice discount bulk food store along with some DI water.

Will clean up some more and see if I can let it sit a couple days?
Don’t need to dissolve the entire bolt…just the ~1mm of most of the threads, really & fish the chunk of it out?

The aggressively marketed (which inherently sows seeds of suspicion in the mind of the skin-flint DIY recycler?) expensive GripEdge extractors with the outer sleeve to pull the extractor back out gradually with a forcing screw instead of attempting to grab onto the extractor with a slide hammer to remove it in situ to abort the mission do look interesting?

((that’s how I broke the extractor in my defense? / not twisting it / was attempting to abort the mission, tho still maybe foolish? / coulda probably waited a couple more days with oil and heated and cooled it a couple more times or called a helper over to hit the block with the torch more precisely as I applied a bit of torque to the extractor to see if it’d give way as the aluminum expanded around the fragment of bolt on initial heating, maybe, but no going back now?).

Literally said ‘I’ve successfully drilled thru the bolt and nothing bad has happened…yet…’
*sigh*
 
Last edited:
Back
Top